Overview

The miniDSP UMA-XL is a distributed MEMS microphone array module designed as an accessory for the UMIK-X multichannel measurement system. Using Analog Devices A2B (Automotive Audio Bus) protocol, these modules can be daisy-chained up to 40 meters with single twisted-pair cables carrying both audio and power. Each module incorporates Knowles MEMS microphones (SPH0655LM4H-1) optimized for acoustic measurement applications. The UMA-XL represents miniDSP’s evolution from single-point measurement tools toward comprehensive distributed array solutions for room acoustics analysis and subwoofer integration tasks.

Scientific Validity

\[\Large \text{0.5}\]

The UMA-XL modules feature Knowles MEMS microphones (SPH0655LM4H-1) with manufacturer claims of low distortion, high AOP (Acoustic Overload Point), and high SNR characteristics [1]. The system operates at 24-bit resolution with 44.1 or 48 kHz sampling rates, providing adequate digital precision for measurement applications. However, specific performance metrics such as frequency response deviation, THD, SNR values, crosstalk specifications, and dynamic range measurements are not available in manufacturer documentation or independent third-party measurements. Without concrete measurement data to evaluate against transparent performance thresholds, the evaluation relies on provisional assessment of established Knowles MEMS technology capabilities and 24-bit digital resolution. The 0.5 score reflects the intermediate position between problematic and transparent levels when measurement data remains unavailable.

Technology Level

\[\Large \text{0.7}\]

The UMA-XL demonstrates strong technological implementation through adoption of Analog Devices A2B protocol, enabling single twisted-pair transmission of multichannel audio plus power over distances up to 40 meters. This automotive-derived technology represents cutting-edge connectivity solutions for distributed measurement arrays, solving traditional complexity issues with multichannel analog setups. miniDSP’s in-house engineering integrates A2B protocol with MEMS microphone technology and measurement software compatibility (REW), creating purpose-built solutions for acoustic measurement professionals. The technology addresses real connectivity and setup challenges in multichannel measurement scenarios, making it desirable for applications requiring distributed microphone placement. Integration of digital signal processing, MEMS sensors, and software compatibility demonstrates appropriate contemporary technology adoption.

Cost-Performance

\[\Large \text{1.0}\]

The UMIK-X system with UMA-XL modules is priced at 550 USD for the basic 8-channel configuration [2]. Equipped with 8-channel omnidirectional measurement capability and 24-bit/48kHz resolution, performance is equivalent-or-better to traditional multichannel approaches using multiple individual measurement microphones. The cheapest equivalent multichannel solution utilizes 8 individual UMIK-1 microphones at approximately 150 USD each (1,200 USD total) [4], providing equivalent 8-channel measurement capability with individual calibration files but requiring separate USB connections. Since no cheaper equivalent exists, the UMA-XL system receives the maximum CP score of 1.0. The system provides significant cost advantages through A2B protocol integration while maintaining equivalent multichannel measurement performance.

Reliability & Support

\[\Large \text{0.3}\]

miniDSP provides a standard one-year warranty on UMA-XL modules, which falls below the typical two-year industry average. The support structure operates through dealer networks with customer-paid shipping costs for warranty returns. While MEMS-based construction with minimal moving parts suggests inherent robustness, community reports indicate “fragile circuit boards on the X version” and occasional support responsiveness concerns [3]. The electronic design should provide reasonable long-term reliability, but the shorter warranty period and reported fragility issues impact the overall assessment. Support infrastructure remains adequate through established dealer channels, though direct manufacturer support requires formal return authorization processes.

Rationality of Design Philosophy

\[\Large \text{0.8}\]

miniDSP demonstrates strong scientific approach through measurement-focused acoustic analysis philosophy, maintaining established partnerships with REW and Dirac Research spanning over 12 years. The A2B protocol implementation directly contributes to functional improvement by enabling simplified cabling for distributed measurement arrays, representing cost-effective technology adoption. Advanced integration of MEMS microphones, digital signal processing, and measurement software creates purpose-built solutions for acoustic measurement applications. The UMIK-X/UMA-XL system represents clear technological progression over single-point UMIK-1/UMIK-2 products in multichannel measurement capability. Technology adoption including A2B protocol, MEMS sensors, and DSP integration directly contributes to measurement performance improvements and installation simplification compared to traditional analog multichannel approaches.

Advice

The UMA-XL modules serve specialized applications requiring distributed multichannel measurement capabilities where traditional single-microphone approaches prove insufficient. Consider this system when conducting comprehensive room acoustics analysis, distributed subwoofer tuning with multiple measurement points, or research applications requiring synchronized multichannel data acquisition. However, for typical home theater optimization, single subwoofer integration, or basic room correction tasks, traditional UMIK-1 approaches provide equivalent measurement accuracy at substantially lower cost. The system’s value proposition strengthens significantly when utilizing the full multichannel capabilities across 8-16 measurement points simultaneously, justifying the premium over single-point alternatives.

References

1. miniDSP, “UMA-XL - A2B MEMS microphone module for UMIK-X,” https://www.minidsp.com/products/acoustic-measurement/uma-xl, accessed 2025-09-08
2. miniDSP, “UMIK-X - USB audio Multichannel Measurement microphone array set,” https://www.minidsp.com/products/acoustic-measurement/umik-x-multichannel-mic, accessed 2025-09-08
3. DIYMobileAudio Forum, “miniDSP UMIK-X or -XL: Downsides?” https://www.diymobileaudio.com/threads/minidsp-umik-x-or-xl-downsides.464825/, accessed 2025-09-08
4. miniDSP, “UMIK-1 - USB Measurement Microphone,” https://www.minidsp.com/products/acoustic-measurement/umik-1, accessed 2025-09-08; current market pricing approximately 150 USD per unit
5. DIYAudio Community, “Measurement mics,” https://www.diyaudio.com/community/threads/measurement-mics.406766/, accessed 2025-09-08

(2025.9.8)