Overview

The Shure PGA58 is a cardioid dynamic vocal microphone designed for professional sound reinforcement and home recording applications. Featuring a tailored frequency response for vocal applications, the microphone incorporates Shure’s traditional dynamic capsule technology with cardioid pickup pattern for background noise isolation. The microphone includes a discrete on/off switch and durable construction intended for live sound environments, representing Shure’s entry-level offering in the vocal microphone segment.

Scientific Validity

\[\Large \text{0.4}\]

The PGA58’s frequency response of 50-16,000 Hz falls between problematic and transparent levels according to microphone measurement criteria. Third-party analysis reveals frequency response variations including roll-off starting at 500Hz, relative flatness through 3kHz, followed by a presence boost peaking at 5.5kHz and steep cut at 6.5kHz [1]. The sensitivity specification of -55 dBV/Pa (1.8 mV) at 1 kHz is within acceptable range for dynamic microphones. Critical specifications including S/N ratio, equivalent noise level, and maximum SPL are not publicly available from manufacturer specifications. While third-party measurement sources provide frequency response analysis, independent lab measurements for noise performance and distortion characteristics remain unavailable, limiting comprehensive performance assessment against measurement criteria requirements. The microphone achieves adequate performance for basic vocal applications but lacks the extended frequency response and measured performance data expected for higher scientific validity ratings.

Technology Level

\[\Large \text{0.4}\]

The PGA58 employs standard dynamic microphone technology with traditional magnetic coil design and cardioid polar pattern. The implementation represents mature, well-established technology without proprietary innovations, advanced patents, or cutting-edge features. The design includes basic on/off switch functionality and low impedance balanced output but lacks modern enhancements such as DSP integration, digital connectivity, or advanced signal processing capabilities. The technology level reflects conventional analog-only approach typical of entry-level products, with no evidence of technical advancement beyond established industry practices from previous decades.

Cost-Performance

\[\Large \text{1.0}\]

At 65 USD, the PGA58 provides basic dynamic vocal microphone functionality with cardioid pattern, on/off switch, and balanced output. No cheaper alternatives with equivalent-or-better performance characteristics were found, establishing the PGA58 as the optimal choice in its price range. Featuring frequency response 50Hz-16kHz, sensitivity -55dBV/Pa, and cardioid dynamic microphone technology, the absence of cheaper products with equivalent functionality and performance results in CP=1.0, demonstrating excellent cost-performance.

Reliability & Support

\[\Large \text{0.5}\]

Shure provides 2-year limited warranty with repair services handled by Shure Incorporated or authorized distribution centers [3]. Extended warranty options are available for additional coverage periods. Service limitations include no advance replacement options, customer responsibility for shipping costs, and standard repair turnaround times. The dynamic microphone construction features simple, robust design with few moving parts, providing inherent resistance to failure and durability suitable for live sound applications. The reliability profile represents average industry standards with basic support infrastructure and reasonable construction quality.

Rationality of Design Philosophy

\[\Large \text{0.5}\]

The PGA58’s design philosophy emphasizes durability and proven analog technology with focus on reliability for live sound applications. The approach prioritizes established dynamic microphone technology with straightforward cardioid pattern implementation and basic functionality including discrete on/off switching. While lacking modern enhancements such as DSP integration or digital connectivity, the design philosophy demonstrates consistency with professional audio standards and maintains focus on core vocal reproduction functionality. The conservative approach reflects traditional microphone design principles with emphasis on robust construction and reliable performance in demanding environments.

Advice

The PGA58 serves as a basic entry point for users requiring fundamental dynamic microphone functionality at moderate cost. No cheaper alternatives with equivalent-or-better performance characteristics were found, establishing the PGA58 as the optimal choice in its price range. For users prioritizing brand reputation and willing to accept premium pricing for standard technology, the PGA58 offers Shure’s build quality and support infrastructure. Professional applications demanding superior frequency response, lower noise specifications, or advanced features should consider higher-tier alternatives with published measurement data and modern technological implementations.

References

[1] Shure PGA58 Dynamic Mic Review / Test — Geeks Rising, https://www.geeksrising.com/shows/2018/3/11/shure-pga58, accessed 2025-09-11

[2] PGA58 - Vocal Microphone - Shure USA, https://www.shure.com/en-US/products/microphones/pga58, accessed 2025-09-11

[3] Product Registration & Warranty Guarantee - Shure USA, https://www.shure.com/en-US/support/warranty, accessed 2025-09-11

[4] PGA58 - Vocal Microphone - Shure USA, https://www.shure.com/en-US/products/microphones/pga58, accessed 2025-09-11

[5] Shure PGA58 Cardioid Dynamic Vocal Microphone

Sweetwater, https://www.sweetwater.com/store/detail/PGA58–shure-pga58-handheld-dynamic-vocal-microphone, accessed 2025-09-11

(2025.9.11)