Overview

The Shure SM58SE (Special Edition) represents a sleek black variant of the legendary SM58 dynamic vocal microphone, featuring an integrated on/off switch for enhanced stage control. This key differentiating feature provides performers with direct control over microphone output without requiring sound engineer intervention. Based on the proven Unidyne III capsule technology from the 1960s, this cardioid dynamic microphone maintains the trusted sound characteristics that have made the SM58 series an industry standard for live vocal performance, while adding practical switching functionality essential for professional stage applications.

Scientific Validity

\[\Large \text{0.3}\]

The SM58SE demonstrates frequency response of 50-15,000 Hz with measurements showing it stays within roughly ±5dB from 200Hz to 10kHz [1]. According to transparent reproduction standards, ±5dB deviation significantly exceeds the ±3.0dB problematic threshold and falls well short of the ±0.5dB transparent level. Third-party measurements confirm a presence boost around 5kHz for vocal clarity, with maximum SPL reaching 144 dB at 1% THD (2500 ohm load) [2]. Additional measurements indicate MAX SPL of 150dB at 100Hz and 160dB at 1kHz [3]. While adequate for vocal applications, the frequency response deviation places performance in problematic territory according to transparent reproduction standards.

Technology Level

\[\Large \text{0.3}\]

Technology foundation relies on the mature Unidyne III capsule design from the 1960s with minimal innovation since original development [4]. Construction employs conventional moving-coil dynamic transducer with pneumatic suspension system and spherical pop filter. While the pneumatic shock-mount system represented innovation in its era, the underlying technology remains fundamentally unchanged for over five decades. The integrated on/off switch provides functional enhancement, but the core design lacks integration of contemporary digital signal processing, software enhancement, or modern materials science that characterize current-generation professional audio equipment.

Cost-Performance

\[\Large \text{0.2}\]

At 109 USD, the SM58SE competes against the Behringer XM8500 (20 USD) which provides equivalent core functions: 50Hz-15kHz frequency response, cardioid pickup pattern, dynamic construction, pop filtering, and shock mounting [5]. Equipped with similar frequency response and cardioid isolation capabilities, the XM8500 delivers comparable functionality. CP = 20 USD ÷ 109 USD = 0.18. The significant price difference demonstrates poor cost-performance, with the cheaper alternative providing essentially equivalent user-facing functions and measured performance specifications.

Reliability & Support

\[\Large \text{0.7}\]

Shure provides 2-year standard warranty with global support infrastructure and professional repair services. The simple moving-coil construction with minimal components ensures excellent long-term reliability, consistent with the SM58 series’ legendary durability in professional environments. Robust dynamic microphone design inherently resists failure, while widespread adoption ensures long-term parts availability and service support throughout the product lifecycle.

Rationality of Design Philosophy

\[\Large \text{0.6}\]

Design philosophy demonstrates measurement-based development with documented frequency response characteristics and proven reliability focus [6]. The addition of the on/off switch addresses practical user requirements while maintaining established acoustic design principles. However, the conservative approach shows limited adoption of modern digital technologies that could enhance functionality beyond traditional analog/mechanical systems. Philosophy prioritizes consistency and reliability over innovation, which proves rational for established professional applications, though the reluctance to incorporate contemporary advances limits potential for meaningful performance improvements compared to modern alternatives.

Advice

The SM58SE suits professional environments where brand reputation and build quality justify significant premium over equivalent alternatives. The 109 USD price represents poor value when functionally equivalent microphones like the Behringer XM8500 provide similar performance at 20 USD. Budget-conscious users should prioritize alternatives offering equivalent specifications at substantially lower cost. Consider this microphone only when specific professional requirements demand established brand recognition or when cost is not a primary consideration.

References

[1] SoundGuys, Shure SM58 review: A stellar performance mic, https://www.soundguys.com/shure-sm58-review-25950/, accessed September 2025 [2] Shure, Shure SM58 Datasheet via Sweetwater, https://media.sweetwater.com/store/media/us_pro_sm58_specsheet.pdf, accessed September 2025 [3] SoundRef, The Definitive Shure SM58 Review, https://soundref.com/shure-sm58-review-vocal-mic/, accessed September 2025 [4] Shure USA, How They Did It: Inside the SM58, https://www.shure.com/en-US/performance-production/louder/how-they-did-it-inside-the-sm58, accessed September 2025 [5] Sweetwater, Behringer XM8500 Cardioid Dynamic Vocal Microphone, https://www.sweetwater.com/store/detail/XM8500–behringer-xm8500-handheld-dynamic-vocal-microphone, accessed September 2025 [6] Shure USA, A Culture of Innovation, https://www.shure.com/en-US/performance-production/louder/a-culture-of-innovation, accessed September 2025

(2025.9.10)